Showing posts with label arson. Show all posts
Showing posts with label arson. Show all posts

Wednesday, May 6, 2009

Former firefighter, 911 dispatcher Blake indicted on arson charges


Nearly 18 months after she was first implicated, a former Mason volunteer firefighter, and daughter of Mason County’s emergency services director has been indicted for her alleged role in a series of Bend-area arsons.

Today, the Mason County Prosecutor’s Office released the names of those indicted by the grand jury for its May term. Among the 33 people indicted was Kimberly Sue Blake on two counts of first degree arson and one count conspiracy.

Blake, 25, a resident of Mason, was first accused of the crimes last year. According to court records, on Jan. 11, 2008, Blake, along with Jamar Juel Cuthbertson and Brent Donavan Kapp were charged by the state Fire Marshal’s Office of deliberately setting fires to several abandoned or unoccupied structures in late 2007.

In the criminal complaint he first filed in Mason Magistrate Court, Assistant Fire Marshal Jason Baltic alleged Cuthbertson, while a member of the New Haven Volunteer Fire Department, of setting fire to an outbuilding at 16698 Ohio River Rd. in West Columbia on Sept. 29, 2007. The Fire Marshal’s investigation also linked Kapp, who at the time was a member of the Mason Volunteer Fire Department, to the fire.

About two weeks later on October 15, Kapp was implicated in another arson. This time, records show he torched an abandoned trailer at 286 Front St. in Mason.

Assisting Kapp in setting the fire was Blake. According to court records, Blake and Kapp were seen pulling into the fire station in a Green Pontiac about 10-15 minutes before the blaze was reported to Mason 911.

At the time of the fire, Blake was a dispatcher for 911 where her father, Chuck, serves as director. Ironically, Blake’s brother, Chuck II, in addition to also being a 911 dispatcher, and chief of the Mason department, was convicted a decade ago for his role in setting fire to the Hogg and Zuspan lumber yard around the corner where she and Kapp set fire to the abandoned trailer.

Though Cuthbertson and Kapp were later indicted during the May 2008 term of the grand jury, the charges against Blake were dismissed on March 3. Mason County Prosecutor Damon Morgan made the motion following Baltic’s failure to appear at Blake’s preliminary hearing.

For reasons still unclear, despite one being issued, a subpoena was never served on Baltic to appear at Blake’s hearing.

Since then, Cuthbertson, 20, and Kapp, 21, have entered guilty pleas in there respective cases. In March, Kapp plead guilty to one count first degree arson and one count second degree arson.

He is scheduled to be sentenced on June 1.

After pleading to one count of second degree arson, Cuthbertson on December 2 was sentenced by Judge David W. Nibert to an indeterminate sentence of six months to two years at the Anthony Correctional Center in Greenbrier County.

According to the state Division of Correction’s Web site, Cuthbertson is scheduled to be released on June 29.

Subsequent to her arrest, Blake was placed on administrative leave with pay from the 911 center. When the Mason County Commission met on March 10 to reconsider reinstating Blake following the dismissal of the charges, she shocked everyone by announcing her resignation.

According to records provided by the commission, Blake’s salary was $23,952.

Following her resignation, commission President Rick Handley told The Point Pleasant Register that the commission would be conducting “a search of its records to see if Blake is due any back pay.” Though it is not immediately clear what if anything the commission has done in that regard, sources tell The Free Press that discrepancies in the 911 payroll prior to Blake’s arrest have resulted in multiple investigations of the Office of Emergency Services by several state agencies.

Also, sources say that Chuck Blake offered to tender his resignation if Kim was ever indicted. Blake was not immediately available for comment concerning either Kim's indictment or a possible resignation.
In West Virginia, a charge of first degree arson carries a prison sentence of 2-20 years.

Blake, along with the 32 other people indicted, have their first-appearance hearing scheduled for Monday, May 11 at 9:30 a.m. in Mason Circuit Court. Below, is a complete list of indictments returned by the Mason grand jury during the May term:

1. Anthony D. Black, 21, Point Pleasant - one count each, burglary and grand larceny.

2. Kimberly Sue Blake, 25, Mason - two counts first degree arson; one count conspiracy.

3. James Thomas Boles, 29, Point Pleasant - two counts identity theft; three counts access device fraud; one count conspiracy.

4. Heather Dawn Bryant, 28, Leon - 10 counts each, forgery and uttering.

5. Glen A. Childers, 34, Point Pleasant - three counts each, forgery and uttering.

6. Anthony James Double, 31, Southside - one count sexual assault in the first degree; two counts sexual abuse in the first degree.

7. Richard Eugene Ellis, 38, Gallipolis, Ohio - one count each, robbery in the first degree and conspiracy.

8. Nicole R. Hager, 24, Gallipolis, Ohio - one count each, burglary and petit larceny.

9. Jonathan Wayne Hanshaw, 31, Milton - one count each, possession of controlled substance with intent to deliver and conspiracy.

10. Jessica Ann Henderson, 26, Milton - one count each, possession of a controlled substance with intent to deliver and conspiracy.

11. Christopher M. Henson, 20, Point Pleasant - one count each, kidnapping, robbery in the second degree and conspiracy.

12. Josh T. Hunter, 25, New Haven - two counts of cruelty to animals.

13. Travis Johnson, Point Pleasant - one count each, kidnapping, robbery in the second degree and conspiracy.

14. Jacque L. Lee, 54, New Haven - one count of delivery of a controlled substance.

15. Evelyn Sue Litchfield, 32, Henderson - one count each, robbery in the first degree and conspiracy.

16. Zachary John MacKnight, 28, Letart - one count each, grand larceny and conspiracy.

17. Arthur Vanburen Meadows, 29, Point Pleasant - one count each, burglary, domestic battery and destruction of property.

18. Theodore Ray Melrose, 69, Point Pleasant - one count of possession of a controlled substance with intent to deliver.

19. Danis Mensah, 25, Bronx, N.Y. - one count each, fraudulent scheme, identity theft and receiving stolen property in another state.

20. Gregory A. Messer, 47, Southside - one count each, wanton endangerment, domestic assault, prohibited person with a firearm; two counts domestic battery.

21. Dustin Ray Millhone, 28, Columbus, Ohio - five counts each of possession of a controlled substance with intent to deliver.

22. Chad Allen Norton, 25, Mason - one count each, breaking and entering and petit larceny.

23. Christopher Ryan Perdue, 29, Welston, Ohio - one count each, possession of a controlled substance with intent to deliver, conspiracy and carrying a concealed weapon.

24. Marco Joe Pickenpaugh, 26, Mason - two counts of delivery of a controlled substance.

25. Jeffrey Lee Rainey, 24, Point Pleasant - one count each, forgery and uttering.

26. Kristin June Roberts, 29, Point Pleasant - two counts identity theft; three counts access device fraud; one count conspiracy.

27. Shannon Lewis Rose, 28, Milton - one count each, breaking and entering and grand larceny.

28. Russell Dean Sargent, 30, Pomeroy, Ohio - one count of second offence petit larceny.

29. Joshua D. Stark, 25, Apple Grove - one count each, grand larceny, destruction of property and conspiracy.

30. Jonathan Mclure Stone, 32, Mason - one count each, grand larceny and conspiracy.

31. Charles Clay Sullivan, 41, West Columbia - two counts of possession of controlled substance with intent to deliver and one count of possession of controlled substance with intent to manufacture.

32. Chad VanMeter, 23, Mason - three counts burglary; two counts petit larceny; one count each, attempted burglary and grand larceny.

33. Joshua Calvin Wears, 26, Pliny - two counts of failure to provide notice of sex offender registry changes.

Photo: In a criminal complaint filed last year, the state Fire Marshal's Office alleges this abandoned trailer on Front Street in Mason was delibertately torched by then-Mason volunteer firefighters Brent Donavan Kapp and Kimberly Sue Blake in October 2007. Though both were charged with arson last year, Blake, a former 911 dispatcher, and daughter of Mason County Office of Emergency Service's Director Chuck Blake, was only indicted for her role in the blaze this week by the Mason grand jury. Kapp, who was indicted during last May's grand jury term, has since entered a guilty plea, and is awaiting sentencing.

Thursday, March 13, 2008

Holy Mothman, Batman! The Charleston Gazette reports controversial news from Mason County!


This article originally appeared in the March 13 edition of the Charleston Gazette, and is reprinted with permission.

Apologize, Mason sheriff says
Remarks about subpoena error went too far, he says


by Gary Harki, staff writer

Mason County Sheriff Scott Simms believes state Fire Marshal Sterling Lewis Jr. owes the entire county an apology because of comments he made about an arson investigation.

Kimberly Sue Blake, a volunteer firefighter and daughter of the county's 911 director, was charged with two counts of first-degree arson in January. She and two other firefighters allegedly started a fire at a Mason building.

But charges against Blake were dismissed after an assistant state fire marshal, Jason Baltic, didn't show up at her hearing. A subpoena for Baltic was issued, but never served.

According to the sheriff, Lewis told WSAZ-TV that the issue with the subpoena was "typical of Mason County." The sheriff believes Lewis meant that the sheriff's office was doing a political favor for the county's 911 director, Chuck Blake, by not serving the subpoena.

"That was definitely his intention," Simms said. "People in positions of power and responsibility need to be responsible when they open their mouth.

The sheriff said his main problem was that Lewis impugned the entire county.

"Anybody who has got a problem with me or wants to call me names or make implications that I'm corrupt, that's fine," Simms said.

"I'm an elected official and I asked for it. ... [But] when a man of his position makes a statement like that about a county, then he is talking about all the people of Mason County and that's wrong and he owes the people of Mason County an apology."

Lewis was out of town until Tuesday, and could not be reached for comment, according to a deputy state fire marshal.

The subpoena was not served because of an honest mistake, Simms said. He said 99 percent of the department's annual 4,500 subpoenas are served in Mason County, and its computer system doesn't record whether subpoenas outside the county have been served.

"It has to be dealt with by hand. That's where the mistake took place," the sheriff said. "After the hearing, when I became aware that the fire marshal hadn't been notified I undertook an internal investigation to understand how that happened.

"I know how it happened. And I am taking measures to fix that so it doesn't happen again."

However, Brent Kapp, one of the other firefighters charged with arson, did have a preliminary hearing and his charges were not dismissed. Simms said he didn't know for sure, but he assumed someone from the fire marshal's office was at Kapp's hearing.

He could not say why that subpoena was apparently served, but the subpoena for Kimberly Blake's hearing was not.

The third firefighter charged, Jamar Cuthberson, waived his right to a preliminary hearing, according to court documents and Mason County Prosecuting Attorney Damon Morgan Jr.

Cuthberson and Kapp are out on bail and their cases are awaiting action by a Mason County grand jury, Morgan said.

Baltic, the assistant fire marshal, said he believes that what happened was a simple mistake.

"I guess you could say in the process there was an oversight," he said. "I didn't receive a subpoena. I wasn't there."

Charges against Blake will still be presented before the grand jury, Morgan said.

"Frankly, in cases in general where a defendant is released on bond, a preliminary hearing never benefits the state unless they are a flight risk," Morgan said.

"It only benefits the defendant because they get to hear the state's case."

Simms said his department has always worked well with Lewis' office and that they will continue that good working relationship.